Match #1: Beside the Ocean vs. Curtain Call
They’re both tragic Nick romances involving cancer, but which one was the most heart-wrenching?
Match #2: Broken vs. Footprints
Whose side of the story would you rather read, Nick’s or Claire’s?
Match #3: By My Side vs. Sick as My Secrets
Which chronically-ill characters make the cutest couple: cancer survivors Nick and Claire or HIV-positive Nick and Howie?
Match #4: Beauty and the Backstreet Boy vs. Shorty and the Deceased
Which Backstreet retelling of Beauty and the Beast do you like best?